Fake or Fortune?

Original version

BBC One Cambridgeshire HD

Factual: Arts, Culture & the Media

Factual: Arts, Culture & the Media: Arts

Journalist Fiona Bruce and art expert Philip Mould investigate mysteries behind paintings.

Fiona Bruce teams up with expert Philip Mould to investigate mysteries behind intriguing works of art. Are they potentially priceless or crafty copies?

Series 11

BBC Two

BBC One London

London

Simulcast of network BBC One in high definition. From 03/11/2010

BBC One HD

Formerly part of a wider BBC One South East region that included London and part of the South region. Separated from BBC One London 2001-09-03 following reorganisation of the South East region.

BBC One South East HD

BBC One North West HD

BBC One region covering Derbyshire, Leicestershire and Nottinghamshire.

BBC One East Midlands HD

BBC One Cambridgeshire

The BBC South region started on 5th January 1961 as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One South.

BBC One South

BBC One West Midlands

BBC One Yorkshire HD

BBC One West Midlands HD

The BBC North East & Cumbria region started in 1959 (tbc) as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One North East & Cumbria.

BBC One North East & Cumbria HD

BBC One Yorks & Lincs HD

The BBC South West region started on 20th April 1961 as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One South West.

BBC One South West

BBC One South East

The BBC East region started on 1st May 1959 as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One East.

BBC One East HD

The BBC West region started on 1st September 1957 as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One West.

BBC One West

BBC One Oxfordshire

BBC One South West HD

BBC One Channel Islands HD

Formerly part of a wider BBC One South East region. Separated as BBC One London 2001-09-03 following reorganisation of the South East region.

BBC One London HD

BBC One Nightlight

BBC One North East & Cumbria

BBC One East

BBC One Yorkshire

BBC One South HD

BBC One Oxfordshire HD

BBC One North West

BBC One Yorks & Lincs

BBC One Channel Islands

BBC One East Midlands

BBC One West HD

Simulcast of BBC One Scotland in high definition. From 14/01/2013

BBC One Scotland HD

BBC One Scotland

Scotland

BBC Northern Ireland region started on 19th April 1955 as part of the BBC Television Service, before becoming BBC One Northern Ireland.

BBC One Northern Ireland

BBC One Wales

Wales

Simulcast of BBC One Northern Ireland in high definition. From 24/10/2012

BBC One Northern Ireland HD

Simulcast of BBC One Wales in high definition. From 29/01/2013

BBC One Wales HD

BBC Two England

England

Simulcast of network BBC Two in high definition.

BBC Two HD

BBC Two Northern Ireland

Simulcast of BBC Two Northern Ireland in high definition

BBC Two Northern Ireland HD

Until 03/01/2009 BBC Two Wales (analogue) was known simply as BBC Two Wales. BBC Two Wales (digital) was BBC 2W. From 03/01/2009 BBC Two Wales schedules on both analogue and digital became identical

BBC Two Wales

Simulcast of BBC Two Wales in high definition

BBC Two Wales HD

Fake or Fortune

Fiona Bruce

Philip Mould

Robert Murphy

Kirsty  Brettle

Julia Foot

Fake or Fortune?: Series 11: Arshile Gorky

Magazines & Reviews

Arshile Gorky

BBC One - Fake or Fortune?, Series 11, Arshile Gorky

Could a mysterious canvas covered in white paint be a lost masterpiece by Arshile Gorky?

Could a mysterious canvas covered in white paint be hiding a lost painting by one of the most important painters of the 20th century, Armenian-American artist Arshile Gorky?

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould investigate a murky canvas that could be by Arshile Gorky, a pioneer of abstract expressionism. Works by this Armenian-American artist fetch millions at auction, but there is one major hurdle in the way of owner Liza Dunluce realising its fortune – the canvas is covered in white paint. 

The picture was a gift to Liza’s late husband Alexander in 1965 when he was keeper of conservation at the Tate Gallery. Alexander was a highly respected restorer of paintings, and Gorky’s widow Agnes ‘Mougouch’ Magruder instructed him to remove the white layer so that the picture could be exhibited in a major retrospective of Gorky’s work. When Alexander couldn’t clean the picture safely in time for the exhibition, ‘Mougouch’ gave it to him. 

Nearly six decades later, the painting remains in the family, partially obscured and unidentified as a work by Gorky. Fed up with not getting any further with it, Liza has asked the Fake or Fortune team to help. At the Courtauld Institute, Professor Aviva Burnstock undertakes technical analysis of the painting to try and determine if there’s a safe solution for cleaning it. A cross-section of the picture reveals that the white top layer is a cheap household paint, different in chemical composition to the more refined artist’s paints underneath. Liza commissions conservators Katya Belaia-Selzer and Eppie Petrina to try and remove the white layer. If they can find a solution that will dissolve the household paint without damaging the paint layer underneath, it’s possible Mougouch’s wish of having the picture restored can finally be realised.

Dates on the back of the canvas suggest it was painted between 1928 and 1931, but what is visible of the original composition through the gaps in the white paint looks nothing like Gorky’s work from this early period of his career. At this time, his style was characterised by geometric shapes and primary colours. The amorphous, brown-toned composition partially visible is much more in keeping with the artist’s later works from the 1940s. This is when Gorky had developed his own enigmatic style that would go on to make him one of the most important American painters of the 20th century.   

Philip hopes an x-ray will explain why the dates on the back of the canvas don’t match the style of the painting on the front. Could there be another, earlier work buried deep beneath the layers of paint? Tantalisingly, Fiona’s research reveals a lost Gorky from the 1930s, known only by a photograph. Could this picture lie hidden beneath a 1940s composition?

A Gorky from the 1940s could be worth several millions, but only if the painting is authenticated by the Gorky Foundation. Events take a turn after the Gorky family go to see the picture and raise a startling question – should the white paint layer be removed at all? The artist’s granddaughter, Saskia Spender, tells Fiona that Gorky sometimes used white paint to partially cover up his pictures as part of the creative process. Could Liza’s canvas be made up of not one, not two, but three pictures – the white layer on top being a further composition?  

Saskia warns that if Liza continues with the removal of the white layer, the Gorky Foundation may not authenticate the work at all, irrespective of whether the artist painted it or not. Liza and the team are faced with an ethical dilemma – should they remove paint that the artist applied or leave the work in a permanent state of limbo?

This proves to be one of the most challenging investigations on the series yet. With millions at stake, will Liza’s picture turn out to be neither Fake nor Fortune?

Accessibility links

Programme Index

Fake or Fortune?

Series 11

Arshile Gorky

Contributors

Genres

Formats

Brand

Series

BBC One Cambridgeshire HD

About BBC One