My Problem with...

My Problem with... Mendelssohn

Original version

BBC Radio 3 is a radio channel that started transmitting on the 30th September 1967. It replaced Third Programme.

BBC Radio 3

Radio 3

My Problem with...: Mendelssohn

22/08/2021

Mendelssohn

BBC Radio 3 - My Problem with..., Mendelssohn

Mahan Esfahani tries couples counselling to rejuvenate his love for Mendelssohn.

Mahan Esfahani tries couples counselling to rejuvenate his love for Mendelssohn. Once a passionate affair, Mahan now finds Mendelssohn’s music predictable, basic and boring.

Mahan Esfahani talks to the conductor Paul McCreesh about his lost love for Mendelssohn. At one time it was a passionate affair. As a budding pianist Mahan looked to the great German composer’s music to show him how to be an adult, to be measured, enlightened and cultivated. But as with many young loves the passion dwindled, his music began to fall flat and became predictable, basic and boring. 

Felix Mendelssohn is a much-loved figure in both German and British music for his ability to recreate the Baroque world with the added spice of 19th-century harmony. An affable character whose compositional style was imitated by many after his death, Mendelssohn is often celebrated for his honesty and simplicity. 

Not wishing to give up on the cherished memories of his youth, Mahan seeks some couples counselling from the conductor Paul McCreesh. The founder and director of the Gabrieli Consort and Players, Paul McCreesh has brought considerable insight and a willingness to experiment to all kinds of repertoire, including his recording of Mendelssohn’s oratorio ‘Elijah’. 

Together they work through the arguments that Mendelssohn is stuck between the Classical and Romantic periods, unsure of his purpose; that the Mendelssohnian style became ubiquitous making it clichéd and that he writes marvellous beginnings and endings, but what’s with all the fluff in the middle? 

Produced by Rebecca Gaskell
A Reduced Listening production for BBC Radio 3

Live music and the arts: broadcasts more live music than any other radio network. Classical music is its core. Genres include world and new music, jazz, speech and drama.

Discussion & Talk

Music: Classical

Mahan Esfahani asks what's wrong with saying you don't like some of the 'great composers'.

Harpsichordist and broadcaster Mahan Esfahani throws down the argument that some of the so-called 'great composers' maybe aren't that great.

Accessibility links

Programme Index

My Problem with...

Mendelssohn

Genres

Series

BBC Radio 3

About BBC Radio 3