Murder, Mystery and My Family: Case Closed? 

Original version

BBC Two

Knowledge, drama, comedy and the arts for a broad adult audience.

BBC Two is a lively channel of depth and substance, carrying a range of knowledge-building programming complemented by great drama, comedy and arts.

BBC Two Northern Ireland

Murder, Mystery and My Family

Documentaries

Factual

Factual: Crime & Justice

Top criminal barristers Sasha Wass and Jeremy Dein reinvestigate historical cases.

Simulcast of BBC Two Wales in high definition

BBC Two Wales HD

BBC Two England

England

Simulcast of network BBC Two in high definition.

BBC Two HD

Until 03/01/2009 BBC Two Wales (analogue) was known simply as BBC Two Wales. BBC Two Wales (digital) was BBC 2W. From 03/01/2009 BBC Two Wales schedules on both analogue and digital became identical

BBC Two Wales

Simulcast of BBC Two Northern Ireland in high definition

BBC Two Northern Ireland HD

Sasha Wass

Jeremy Dein

Mike Benson

Michael Klokkos

Simon Cooper

James Pearson

Emily Wallis

Clare Wales

Chalkboard TV

Murder, Mystery and My Family: Case Closed? Series 4: Lowson

Lowson

Case Closed? Series 4

BBC One - Murder, Mystery and My Family, Case Closed? Series 4, Lowson

Sasha and Jeremy revisit the brutal murder of a policeman from County Durham in 1884.

The barristers revisit a fascinating case from 1884 in County Durham where three men stood trial for the murder of a policeman, yet only one man faced the death sentence.

Leading criminal barristers Sasha Wass QC and Jeremy Dein QC revisit their investigation into the brutal murder of a policeman. Three men were tried for the crime, but only one was hanged. 

Butterknowle, County Durham, 1884. On a dark and rainy Saturday night, following a pigeon-shooting competition, Police Sergeant William Smith was out doing his rounds at pub closing time. Suddenly, a group of three men emerged from the darkness and brutally attacked him. The assault was so severe that his skull was fractured, and he was left for dead in the road. Two passing doctors went to the wounded sergeant’s aid, and he was carried to his house. But a couple of hours later, Sergeant Smith died from his horrific injuries.

Suspicion fell on three local miners who had been drinking in Butterknowle that evening. Among them was 25-year-old Joseph Lowson. Lowson’s brother-in-law William Siddle had previously been charged with assaulting Sergeant Smith, and the two of them were arrested along with friend Joseph Hodgson.

The three men stood trial together at the Durham Assizes, all desperately protesting their innocence. The two doctors gave identification evidence against the three miners, and Lowson was linked to the crime by a button found at the scene that was missing from his shirt.  
 
Hodgson was acquitted by the jury, but Lowson and Siddle were both found guilty and sentenced to death. At the last minute, Siddle was reprieved and on 27 May 1884, Joseph Lowson, alone, was hanged.

Over 100 years later, Joseph Lowson’s great-great-nephew Peter and his wife Diane enlisted the help of the barristers to explore the case. Jeremy and Sasha met an identification expert and forensic scientist to re-evaluate the evidence against Lowson that proved so damning at trial. In a case where three men stood trial and only one was executed, could they find anything to question the original verdict? 

Now, a year on from their initial investigation, the barristers learn how Diane and Peter responded to the judge's verdict. Do revelations about what happened to Joseph Hodgson's co-defendants after the trial throw new doubt on his conviction?

Murder, Mystery and My Family: Case Closed? Series 4

BBC One

Barristers Sasha and Jeremy follow up on some of the cases they have re-examined.

Accessibility links

Programme Index

Murder, Mystery and My Family

Case Closed? Series 4

Lowson

Contributors

Genres

Formats

Brand

Series

BBC Two Northern Ireland

About BBC Two