Original version

BBC Radio 3 is a radio channel that started transmitting on the 30th September 1967. It replaced Third Programme.

BBC Radio 3

Radio 3

The Essay Podcast

The Essay

Discussion & Talk

Factual: Arts, Culture & the Media

Essays from leading writers on arts, history, philosophy, science, religion and beyond.

Leading writers on arts, history, philosophy, science, religion and beyond, themed across a week - insight, opinion and intellectual surprise.

The Essay: A Passion for Opera

The Essay: A Passion for Opera: Episode 3: Robert Thicknesse

A Passion for Opera

Episode 3

Episode 3: Robert Thicknesse

Robert Thicknesse

BBC Radio 3 - The Essay, A Passion for Opera, Robert ThicknesseClose menu

Critic Robert Thicknesse explains why he has fallen out of love with opera.

Critic Robert Thicknesse explains why he has fallen out of love with opera: its opulence, the claims of broad appeal, the disproportionate funding and the audiences.

Robert Thicknesse still sees and writes about opera and he still believes that at its heart there is an argument that can be made for it as an artform. However the old love which he lavished on it in his youth and as a young critic has gone. 

He talks about the demons that have nagged at him over the years, the sheer opulence of the operatic world, the claims of broad appeal which he believes are false, the disproportionate funding, the excuses for modernity and above all the festival audiences who are there unashamedly for the event rather than the performance.

Is this really the greatest of all the artforms? Isn't it more honest to admit that it's a pastime of the rich and, other than a flirtation with mass appeal in 19th century Italy, that's how it has always been?

But Robert also tries to explain why he keeps coming back to opera, given that it isn't to be seen in all the right places and to be seen, most importantly, to be rich.

Live music and the arts: broadcasts more live music than any other radio network. Classical music is its core. Genres include world and new music, jazz, speech and drama.

Documentaries

Factual: Life Stories

Music: Classical: Opera

Series in which people linked with the world of opera describe their relationship to it

Series in which five people associated with the world of opera describe their relationship to it. With contributions from writers, critics and those involved in staging opera

Accessibility links

Programme Index

The Essay

A Passion for Opera

Episode 3: Robert Thicknesse

Genres

Brand

Series

BBC Radio 3

About BBC Radio 3