Two new pirates, Al-Hoy and Arrlice, are shipwrecked on the island and want to replace Cook and Line. Captain HeyHo suggests a pirate competition to help her decide who the better pirates are.

Later on in the cove, the competition hots up as Al-Hoy and Arrrlice come face to face with Cook and Line. But who will be the better pirates? The final decision rests with Captain HeyHo. Show less