In the second of two programmes, Judge
James Pickles gives a unique insight into the mind of a serving judge, and how he exercises power over people's lives. He discusses his views with Roger Wilkes and debates with offenders and a criminologist.
2: Pickles on Punishment Does prison do any good?
The judge confronts people he sent to prison, including the 'king of the Kop', a former soccer hooligan, and argues, with the criminologist and magistrate Professor Terence Morris , that heavy sentences can deter.
Producers HELEN BOADEN and BRIAN WALKER BBC Manchester
(Re-broadcast on Friday at 8.20pm)