- Unknown:
- Guelfo Civinini
- Unknown:
- Carlo Zangarini
- Play By:
- David Belasco
- Minnie:
- Carol Neblett (soprano)
- Jack Ranee, the sheriff:
- Sherrill Milnes (baritone)
- Ramerrez, a Mexican bandit, masquerading under the name of Dick Johnson:
- Placido Domingo (tenor)
- Nick, bartender at the Polka:
- Francis Egerton (tenor)
- Ashby, agent of the Wells Fargo Company:
- Robert Lloyd (bass)
- Miners: Sonora:
- Jonathan Summers (baritone)
- Trin:
- John Dobson (tenor)
- Sid:
- Malcolm Rivers (baritone)
- Bello:
- Tom McDonnell (baritone)
- Harry:
- Paul Crook (tenor)
- Joe:
- Robin Leggate (tenor)
- Happy:
- William Elvin (baritone)
- Larkens:
- Malcolm King (bass)
- Billy Jackrabbit, a Red Indian:
- Paul Hudson (bass)
- Wowkle, his squaw:
- Anne Wilkens (mezzo-Soprano)
- Jake Wallace, a travelling minstrel:
- Gwynne Howell (bass)
- Jose Castro, a member of Ramerrez's gang:
- Eric Garrett (bass)
- Pony Express rider:
- Handel Owen (tenor)
